
So yesterday I wrote a needlessly lengthy post about The Strokes, or more accurately my experience(s) with The Strokes. I promised I'd give my thoughts on the new album so let's get right to it, after a very quick explanation of my feelings re: the previous three albums.
Is This It? (2001) - Easily a desert island disc for me, potentially my favorite album of all time. I will fight people who disrespect this album. Not really, but I'd want to.
Room On Fire (2003) - A worthy follow-up to their debut, ROF didn't take any chances but it delivered another strong set of ten songs that arguably doesn't have a dud in the bunch which can't really be said about "Is This It?", When It Started anyone? I realize that's only on the US release but it proves my point so it counts.
First Impressions of Earth (2006) - Somewhat unfairly maligned, bloated album that features arguably the best song The Strokes ever did (You Only Live Once). People often make that point that it would've been a much better album with a shorter track list and I have trouble disagreeing. We'd probably all be better off if we never heard Evening Sun and 15 Minutes but songs like YOLO, Razorblade, and Ize of the World redeem the album a fair amount in my opinion.
Which brings us to...
Angles (2011) - I'll give my thoughts on the album as a whole at the end but first I'll foolishly comment on each track.
1. Machu Picchu - I've heard/read people comparing this song to Phoenix, Duran, Duran, and Men At Work among others. The first time I listened to it I was thrown for a bit of a loop, I'm almost 100% sure that it's the guitar riff that apes Michael Jackson's "Wanna Be Starting Something" that was responsible for this. This song has grown on me though and while it doesn't follow in the tradition of great opening Strokes tracks (Is This It?, What Ever Happened?, and You Only Live Once) it's still a solid song.
2. Under Cover of Darkness - Out for over a month now, if you care about The Strokes you've probably heard this song at least once already. This is easily the most "classic Strokes" song on the album and it might also be the best. Don't really think much more needs to be said about this one.
3. Two Kinds of Happiness - It feels like people have been waiting for The Strokes to turn into The Cars for years now. I remember when 12:51 first came out everybody thought "Room On Fire" would be the album that turned Julian Casablancas into Ric Ocasek. If "Angles" weren't so weird/schizophrenic it might've been the album to pull that off. From the opening drum beats and riff you know exactly which automotive band The Strokes are challenging. Julian even throws in some Ocasek vocal tics to blow their cover just in case you may have missed it in the first place.
4. You're So Right - This is where things begin to get messy. Apparently this is bassist Nikolai Fraiture's stab at writing a song for the band. Unfortunately, the lamest Stroke is responsible with one of the lamer songs on the album. To me this song just sounds like a thinner version of River of Brakelights from Julian Casablancas's solo effort "Phrazes For The Young". At least it's pretty short, making it that much more skippable.
5. Taken For A Fool - So far this seems like one of the more enjoyable "Angles" tracks to sing along to in your car to (very important factor for me). It has a very catchy chorus and a good line or two (I'm partial to "Monday Tuesday is my weekend" even though I can't relate to it whatsoever). I've read a lot of people comparing Julian's singing in the verses to the Red Hot Chili Peppers and Talking Heads. This is no doubt due to some staccato phrasing Julian uses. I hear more RHCP than I do David Byrne but I'm going to go ahead and agree with the Talking Heads comparisons because, well, David Byrne >>>>>>>>> Anthony Kiedis.
6. Games - This might be the biggest departure on the album from anything The Strokes have done previously. The chorus is drenched in more keyboards than anything the band has done previously. Lots of people saying this The Strokes taking a stab at "chillwave" (I know, I hate that genre name just as much as you do) and a friend of mine described it as "Elvis Costello meets The Cars". As for me, I'm struggling to find a good comparison but I either way this song is really growing on me. Julian veers dangerously close to an unlistenable falsetto when he sings "I'm ok, I'm alright, I was out late last night" (one of the best lines on the album in my opinion, I can absolutely relate to that one as I've uttered it many late mornings/early afternoons while making a beeline to the bathroom and/or nearest glass of water) as the track climaxes but he gets out just in time.
7. Call Me Back - First thing that came to my mind when initially hearing this song was Stroke Fab Moretti's side project Little Joy. I think the cassette tape hiss in the background only adds to this vibe as Little Joy's album had a bit of a low-fi bent to it. I've seen this track get panned a decent amount already as if it's the worst song on the album which I think is unfair. Granted the breakdown in the second half of the song induces some cringes from yours truly but it's not nearly as bad as what comes a couple tracks later.
8. Gratisfaction - "I want Thin-Lizzy style, kung-fu rock with cool 80's melodies" - Julian Casablancas when asked about the new Strokes album in 2009. Gratisfaction is pretty much just that, The Strokes doing a take on Thin Lizzy and it's...ok. It kind of just makes me want to listen to an actual Think Lizzy song instead. This song also features backing vocals (as do a few others on the album) which as far as I know is a first for The Strokes.
9. Metabolism - I may have gone a little easy on Call Me Back before but that's only because I knew this song was just around the corner. In my mind this is without any question the worst track on the album. It starts off with a very similar riff to Heart In A Cage (a mediocre track off of FIOE) and doesn't get any better from there. From that point the song turns into what is basically The Strokes doing a Muse song. I suppose there are some people who might be into that sort of thing but I am anything but a Muse fan. This is an unfortunate addition to their catalog but as my friend who made The Cars/Elvis Costello comparison earlier said, at least it's not seven minutes long.
10. Life Is Simple In The Moonlight - The Strokes have a solid history of closing tracks to albums. Take It Or Leave It is a classic, I Can't Win is one of my favorite songs off of ROF, and Red Light is a nice song that gets overlooked. LISITM doesn't come close to TIOLI or ICW but I can't really say it's a lot better or worse than Red Light. My understanding is that this is one of the only songs on this album that Julian has a sole songwriting credit on which makes sense is true. Most of the song grooves like a typical Strokes track with the only glaring issue in the song being the completely unnecessary "don't try to stop us" that Julian tags onto the end of the chorus.
So there you have it, those are pretty much my thoughts after spending a good 48 hours with the entirety of "Angles" (I was familiar with about half the songs on the album before the whole thing finally leaked Sunday). I've probably listened to the entire thing 5 or 6 times now and while I was initially underwhelmed, some of the new songs are starting to grow on me. My initial disappointment was probably heavily influenced by the songs I already knew being the better tracks for the most part. As it stands now this album seems like a high 6/low 7 to me with that rating obviously subject to change as I spend more time with it. I think the real question about this album (at least for me) is how it stacks up to "First Impressions of Earth". Will it be regarded as a step in the right direction for the band or part of a continuous decline? I don't think it's really fair to say one way or another just yet but the next several days should be very interesting as we get to watch the Internet sink their teeth into "Angles" and see whether or not The Strokes get torn to shreds or manage to stay relevant in the end.
